Thursday, October 22, 2009

Time for tougher citizenship laws

From The Australian:

KEVIN Rudd is considering changes to allow authorities to take action against new Australian citizens who act in defiance of values underpinning their citizenship.

The Prime Minister said yesterday he was reflecting on the adequacy of citizenship laws after news that a Sydney man had been arrested for allegedly harassing the families of Australian soldiers killed in Afghanistan.

On Wednesday, the Australian Federal Police charged self-styled Muslim cleric Sheik Haron for allegedly writing letters to widows calling the dead Diggers pigs and murderers.

The sheik, understood to go by a variety of names, has been charged with using a postal service to "menace, harass or cause offence". He was granted conditional bail, to reappear on November 10.

Mr Rudd yesterday described the case as stomach-churning, but said he would not comment in detail because it was under investigation.

*snip*

NSW RSL president Don Rowe said if Sheik Haron were found guilty he should "not be allowed to live in Australia and enjoy the freedom which has been so valiantly fought (for) and sacrificed by our young men".

Sheik Haron allegedly wrote to Mr Rudd in February claiming that the Black Saturday bushfires that killed 173 people were retribution for Australian support of the execution in Indonesia of militants convicted of the deadly 2002 Bali nightclub bombings.

Immigration barrister John Gibson said there were grounds for the government to take action against a person if the applicant had lied in their application for permanent residence.

But he said it was "far more complex" where a person had obtained citizenship by conferral. "Once you become a citizen, for better or for worse you're a part of the country," he told The Australian.


"Once you become a citizen, for better or for worse you're a part of the country."

Australia has been throwing around citizenship like confetti for decades. Given our ridiculously lax citizenship laws, it is hardly surprising that we have miscreants like Sheik Haron now residing in our country.

Personally, I think Australia should emulate Switzerland's citizenship laws, the toughest in the Western world.

As this article explains:

Switzerland already has the strictest naturalization rules in Europe. If you want to become Swiss you must live in the country legally for at least 12 years—and pay taxes, and have no criminal record—before you can apply for citizenship. It still does not mean that your wish will be granted, however, and the fact that you were born in Lausanne or Lugano does not make any difference. There are no “amnesties” and illegals are deported. Even if an applicant satisfies all other conditions, the local community in which he resides has the final say: it can interview the applicant and hold a public vote before naturalization is approved. If rejected he can apply again, but only after ten years.

33 comments:

Anonymous said...

As a seventh generation Australian with British ancestry I have to say this is where British or British colonized countries are just plain stupid to themselves in our modern day. Not the people but the governments and those that hold the power.

The very nature of what made Australia the lucky country is very much under threat by the ease at which these types of people can walk into our country, AND somehow be protected, and this is an issue that HAS to be taken in hand before (if not already) it is too late. I fear very much for my children and future decendants based upon the careless stupidity within decisions being made today that effect every facet of our lives. The people they are giving citizenship to today are people seeking to create a new Australia based on their lifestyle and values not the lifestyle and values that are currently in place and that many of us have enjoyed growing up in.

I don't have a problem with people of any nationality, skin colour or background being given citizenship, BUT I do have a problem with those who do not assimilate but in turn expect us to change our way of life and thinking to their ways and bring the trouble of their countries to our country.... Of which our government is playing patsy to in an attempt to win the popularity contest of world governments and leaders.

Thank you for sharing this important issue.

Hope you don't mind if I pass this link onto many that I know will be interested.

Anonymous said...

There are some not-so-amusing (because the content is serious) -about immigration and illegal immigrants; the basic message is: try doing this' in THEIR country - you will probably get yourself shot!

I think we need a 'Citizens of Australia' - Union! Having a democratically elec ted government doesn't seem to cut it, does it!?!

Agent Provocateur
www.somethingfunnygoingon.com

Also a supporter at

http://candobetter.org

Anonymous said...

The problem with a lot of this is the "protection" visa scam. Previously it was a temporary visa so holders could be removed if they broke the rules, protection visas are now permanent residence visas. Unlike other PR visas, applicants have instant access to Medicare and Centrelink. The other thing is that they are allowed an Australian travel document to then return to the country or regime they sought "protection" from. Kind of ironic, isn't it? This is of course so they can bring the rest of their family to Australia to be "protected" i.e. supported by Australian taxpayers. The refugee advocates clue these people up in all their "privileges" so they know exactly what buttons to press "trauma", "persecution" etc often with scant evidence of their situation. Many turn out to not have any need for protection but once granted, it cannot be revoked except under extreme circumstances. Then, most of these people who arrived before 2007, only needed two years before they "qualified" as citizens. It's a ridiculous system prone to abuse.

Anonymous said...

Just noticed this blog, seems to have a lot in common with our new one, expat-run, in Jakarta. Try it!
Ross's Right Angle
ross.indonesiamatters.com

Naturalization Test said...

thanks for sharing this issue, applications of immigration is really getting hard now...maybe I just need to have patience about this..

Anonymous said...

We need a new political party that will protect the Australian way of life and put the health, happiness and prosperity of the Australian people first. This is just a set of priorities I cannot see anywhere in Aussie politics today. We need 500 authentically passionate and forward-looking Aussies to get the party off the ground and to help formulate a set of policies that can the Australian political landscape. I'm thrilled to discover this blog and will also check out some of the links left by the commenters here. Please stop by and help to start something that will set Australia back on a pathway that will allow our grandchildren to grow up in the kind of Australia that would make us proud.
http://500greataustralians.wordpress.com

Canada Visa said...

Immigration on a whole is very beneficial to Canada and its residents. History tells repeatedly that it is human kind that loses its previleges. Immigration is good for Canada and its people in any way you consider but the undeue advantage taken by a few people in the name of refugee act bestowed by Canadian government is being highly misused. We have to wait and see how far Canada can allow people in the name of refugees. Of course, humanitarian concerns are to be given the highest priority for human kind’s development and survival but misuse of a syustm is highly deplorable. Let us all pray that the gates of immigration be not closed for all those good people and eligible aspirants just because of the refugees who infiltrate this country and can be a bigger and unsolvable problem. As of now Canada is large in heart and resources.

immigration lawyers said...

such a nice article you share with us.

immigration lawyers said...

thanks to share this issue with us.

Ways of legal migration to the United States and the conditions for citizenship said...

Thanx
This Best Blog

Anonymous said...

It’s time to ZIP up the borders!

1735099 said...

In the absence of real leadership on the asylum seekers issue, it takes some non-politicians to say what our elected leaders should have been saying since 2001.

An extract from - http://www.erc.org.au/index.php?module=pagemaster&PAGE_user_op=view_page&PAGE_id=145

"As the Vietnam War came to a chaotic end, Australia faced the prospect of a huge influx of refugees from the conflict. Fears for the well-being of asylum seekers, as well as concerns about whether Australia could successfully deal with such an influx, were well founded. A balance was struck however, and a humane and effective bi-partisan solution was put in place. Both Government and Opposition rose above party affiliation to act in the face of initially negative opinion polls.

Australia’s elected leaders created a system that worked with regional partners, ensured basic human rights protections and created an efficient and effective system which, over 20 years, dealt with the needs of more than 2.5 million Indochinese refugees. The system initiated by the Fraser Government ultimately resulted in some 250,000 Vietnamese refugees and immigrants being taken in. Many of these people were fleeing a war in which Australia was a combatant. We had a moral responsibility to assist them, and we did".

Somehow, our national values have been shouted down by politicians since Howard, using xenophobia as a weapon, and we have forgotten this.

It's time someone knocked Abbott's and Gillard's heads together.

Australia Immigration said...

Speaking from another perspective, I think Australian laws on Immigration has become tougher than ever. Having said that, I don't mean it's not appropriate. Rather, we should realise that we need a better system which can identify legal and trustful immigrants who have studied and worked ethically in Australia. And at the same time, we should be able to identify who has come illegally.

The reason I said that is I know some people who have come legally are actually illegal immigrants. They have taken advantage of some certain weak points in the laws to make them become legal.

Therefore, making the system harder does not necessarily mean the quality of immigrants who have come here will be increased.

Anonymous said...

Their are changes in the terms and the laws of citizenship and visa depending on the terms and condition. Consult the best immigration attorney for any type of immigration, visa or citizenship query to find the right solutions.

Citizenship Application said...

As year passes, immigration processing standards are becoming tougher in other countries too. This is to control the people coming in and out, and to protect the citizens too.

Unknown said...

Eye on Immigration is best that no one visit illegal & not frighten any more. This is necessary aspect for all. Our have californiaimmigration.us and lot of cases have seen.

Unknown said...

Immigration consultants are the professionals who help you with understanding the policies, the grading system which in turn depends upon work experience; proficiency in language etc.immigration consultant chandigarh are the best and provide best services

Jhon Staphen said...

I am speculating, of course. But my point is that the argument about drownings at sea ignores the total picture of what is going on.
no 1 singapore migration agents

Unknown said...

Salvo Property Group will always introduce the ideal residential properties by offering you a gratifying and contemporary lifestyle to its residents significantly with the magnificent Platinum residential property. For more details, read an article about the Platinum project of Salvo Property Group here: Property Developer.

EmilyJacob said...

Splendid, i think immigration is best approach for every citizen.Immigration is a legal way and compulsory to solve your problem.i think this is very beneficial information for every visitor.I also offering online legal services like Family Based Immigration USA, Green Card Petition for Spouse, Finance Visa Requirements, e-2 Treaty Investor K1 Fiance Visa Attorney, US Citizenship Marriage, e-2 Treaty Investor etc.Thanks for sharing this information.

FatherJon said...

Update on Sheik Haron. High Court judgement, but it was touch and go, as you can see:-

http://www.news.com.au/national/high-court-rules-on-constitutional-appeal-of-sheik-man-haron-monis/story-fncynjr2-1226587155679

Unknown said...

Continental Immigration is a leading Australia immigration consultant in New Delhi. It has set a new benchmark for those who want to study in Australia or work in Australia. We pledge to deliver the best of our efforts to help you with migration to Australia. Get in touch with Continental Immigration today and learn how to migrate to Australia in few easy steps.

Anonymous said...

iKNOWN THAT BEEN A HARD POLICYS ABOUT
CITIZENSHIP LAWS.BUT EVERY THINGS WE MUST HAVE LOOK IN A DIFFERENT PERPCTIVES WAYS,I COULD AGREE WITH THE POLICYS,BUT NOT EVRY ONE ARE BAD
,WHAT HAPPPENEBD TO ME IT WAS OUT OF REACH,SINCE I BEEN WAIT FOR 10 YEARS
CLEAN,AND TRY MY HARD TO STAND UP ON MY FFET AFTER LONGS PERIOS OF TIME BEEN IN THE DRUGS CIRCLE,,AFTER I APPLY FOR CITIZENSHIP,GOT REFUSED ON THE BAD CHARACTER SESION,WHEN I WAS
WORRKING AND HAVE A LOTS OF REFERENVES,FROM DOCTOR FROM CATHOLIC CHURCH,,BUT THEY THINK I DID MAKE IT UP MYSELF WITH ALL THAT
REFERENCES THAT I GOT,,I DID WENT TO APPLEAL,AND AT HEARING THEY DID CONFIRM THAT ALL THE REFERENCES WAS TRUE,SO THEY GAVE ME ANOTHER REFUSED RESPONED INSTESD OF BAD CHARACTERS,THIS TIME THEY SAY THAT;WAS UNBANLANCE,,I ASK WHAT IS UNBALANCE,,THAY SAY BECAUCE IN THE PAST YOU HAG ALOT CRIMINAL HISTORY
,I SAID YOU EVEN SAID THAT THE PAST,APFTER I LODLED THE APPEAL FORM,FEWS MONTHS LATER THERE WERE,
GROUPS OF PEOPLE THEY CALLED WAS
THE SAFE GUARD SYSTEM,,THIS SYSTEM NOT EVEN IN PUBLIC AWARENESS YET
I CAN NOT USE BY WORDS HOW TO EXPLAIN IT..PEOPLE MIGHT THINK I AM CRAZY OR I MADE IT UP THE STORY
BUT SUDEENLY ONE DAY I WENT HOME ,I HEARS PEOLE FROM ABOVE WHERE I LIVED,,BEEN MONITOR ME AND TAPPING MY
EVERY MOVEMNET EVEN I WENT TO TOILET I CAN HEAR THE TAPPING NOISE
FROM ABOVE MY TOILET RROM,AT FIRST COUPLE MONTHS,I THNK I MUST HAVE SOME THINHS WRONG WITH MU MENYAL STATE,,,BUT I WENT OUT AND MEET FEWS PEOPLE WHO HAD THE SAME INCIDENT WITH ME,,,I WENT TO LEGAL AID,SHE TOLD ME JUST WRITE ANY DOWN WHAT HAPPENED,SAME TINE I SAT BACK,AND READ WHAT I BEEN WROTE I FIND IT SHOCKING AND REALY DISTURBING,IT IS NOT HARM IN THE PHYSICAL WAY ,,BUT THIS WAS MORE MUCH SERIOUS THAN PEOPLE THEY BEEN PLAY WITH YOUR MINDS,,I CAME TO AUSTRALIA SINCE 15 YEARS OF AGES AND I AM NEARLY 50 MYSELF,,31 YEARS
LIVED IN THIS COUNTRY I NEVER WITNESST ANY THINHS LIKE THIS IN MY LIFE..SOORRY ABOUT MY WRITING IN ENGLISH,,I HARDLY WRITE ANY THINGS,SINCE I LEFLT SCHOOL SINCE 1990

Anonymous said...

YOU JUST CAN NOT PUT EVERY PEOPLE IN ONE CATEGORY I DO AGREE WITH A PERSON WRITE THE FIRST COMMENT,THERE WERE PEOPLE WHICH HAD BRING THEIR H BAD HABITS WAY AND BRING BAD REPUTATION SO IT EFFECT SOME ONE ELSE ,NOT EVERY CAME TO THIS COUNTRY FOR BETTER LIFE,MOST OF THEM ON POLITICAL REASONS ,EVERY YEAR GOVERNMENT ISSUES DIFFERENT POLICY BUT YOU NEVER KNOWN THERE MIGHT PEOPLE OUT THERE ,NOT CARRY OUT THE SAME ORDER,FOR EXAMPLE ,THERE WAS APPLY WITH PEOPLE WHO HAD CRIMINAL RECORD IN THE PAST,FAIR ENOUGH YOU CAN NOT ARGUMENT TO THAT BUT IN CASE IF THERE WERE PEOPLE MAKE THEY TRY TO Make an effort to changed their life or not offended any more crimes but still put in the same category with people still on to crimes.that i think it is not right,if you make it hash ,it should apply to the right profiles,the reason i said this because i seen few people got refused for citizenship 3 times which he should meet all requirement,just because they had criminal history in the past,and got put in the same with the other who might be dangerous and risk to the COMMUNITY I THINK IT IS NOT FAIR

Addison pf said...

I am about to tell you about Salvo migration? In depth analysis of Salvo migration can be an enriching experience. Cited by many as the single most important influence on post modern micro eco compartmentalism, it is impossible to overestimate its impact on modern thought. It is an unfortunate consequence of our civilizations history that Salvo migration is rarely given rational consideration by socialists, obviously. Here begins my indepth analysis of the glourious subject of Salvo migration.

Unknown said...

Hello,
Your blog is very nice it has so helpful to us so thanks for sharing this valuable information. We also providing same services . please have a look our website and give your good advice's.Canada Immigration Services in Hyderabad

elisa robert said...

Nice Blog
.The information what your providing in this article is very userfriendly for those who want to migrate aboard. Iam very glad for having this information.

agenayamterpercaya said...

wow! pertandingan yang sangat seru dari meron dan wala untuk anda yang mau menonton klik disini!
dan dapatkan seputar sabung ayam hanya di sini http://www.sateayam.org
https://agenayamterpercaya.hatenablog.com/entry/2018/06/18/180541

Panggang Ayam Marketing said...

AWESOME THE PROMOTION OF GIRL BEAUTIFUL SALES KLIK HERE

GOOD PRICE AND CHEAP
http://www.gorengayam.org 


PLEASE PRICE DIRECTLY

https://www.diigo.com/item/note/6i7ae/ikws?k=db10ab439026928b2d3ac1ba81ac6e9f

Kyle Walker said...

WINNING303 - JUDI BOLA ONLINE | CASINO ONLINE | SLOT ONLINE | POKER ONLINE TERPERCAYA

BOLA 303

CASINO 303

TOGEL 303

TOGEL POKER

BANDAR BOLA ONLINE TERPERCAYA

* KUNJUNGI SITUS KAMI DI *

www.winning303.net


*NB : MENANG BERAPAPUN, PASTI KAMI BAYAR !!! *

* Melayani LiveChat 7 x 24 Jam Nonstop :
- WA : +6281717177303
- BBM : WINNING303
- LINE : WINNING303*

Kyle Walker said...

WINNING303 - JUDI BOLA ONLINE | CASINO ONLINE | SLOT ONLINE | POKER ONLINE TERPERCAYA

BOLA 303

CASINO 303

TOGEL 303

TOGEL POKER

BO POKER

* KUNJUNGI SITUS KAMI DI *

www.winning303.net


*NB : MENANG BERAPAPUN, PASTI KAMI BAYAR !!! *

* Melayani LiveChat 7 x 24 Jam Nonstop :
- WA : +6281717177303
- BBM : WINNING303
- LINE : WINNING303*



DAFTAR SEKARANG

Gulai Ayam Marketing said...


Judi Sabung Ayam Online S128


Daftar Sabung Ayam S128


Agen Bola

Bilal said...

Appreciate you for this amazing blog and it is good for those who are looking for immigration information. Keep sharing. canadian immigration consultants